FileMaker 9 Tip#2: Disabling a Button

Leave a comment

7-10-2007 by Geoff Coffey

In the old days, we used to joke that FileMaker’s user interface tools were stuck in the 1970s. You could make a long list of things every application in the world did that were hard to do in your own FileMaker-based systems. In the last several years, though, FileMaker Inc. has knocked a lot of biggies off this list: Custom Menus, Tab Controls, modern-looking check boxes and radio buttons. Oh wait, scratch that last one.

Now we’re left to fuss about things that are a lot less significant. But one area of constant annoyance in my user interface work is disabled buttons. I got my first Mac in 1986, and way back then, if some button on the screen just didn’t apply, it was sensibly grayed out, giving the user a clear indication that it wasn’t worth clicking. But in FileMaker, if you put a button on a layout, it has just one look. Even if you-the-wise-developer know exactly when it shouldn’t be clicked, you have no simple way to tell your user. Or do you?

Sometimes, when it was important enough, you may have added a calculation field to the table that you could layer over the top of the button to simulate grayed out text. But anyone whose read much on this blog knows I’m loathe to add anything but real data to my tables. So this method, while possible, is far from perfect.

Today, though, with the release of FileMaker 9, you now have a fantastic option for disabling buttons: use Conditional Formatting. Most of the conditional formatting examples you’ve seen have focused on fields and field labels. But FileMaker dutifully lets you assign conditional formatting to a standard button as well.

Just select the button and choose Format -> Conditional. You can tell FileMaker to turn the button’s label and/or fill color to a lighter shade of whatever under any condition you can dream up (you use a calculation formula to decide when each custom format applies).

Here’s a closeup of one of my databases before and after this technique is applied:

FileMaker Layout buttons before Conditional Formatting   FileMaker Layout buttons after Conditional Formatting

Can you guess which one comes from a record with no email address? Thought so.

Editors Note: I’m sure Geoff meant to add this but it must have slipped his mind…. This method for disabling buttons just makes the button **appear** to be disabled. Don’t confuse this for actually disabling the button completely. To kill the button completely, I would suggest using a custom function in your conditional formating. It should return `true` when the button should be clickable. Then you can just put that same custom function in an If block around your script too like so:

If [ my custom function ]
// all my scripting stuff
End If

Now you have yourself a completely disabled button! The last nice addition would be to get that darn arrow to disappear…. but alas… the FileMaker 9 gods have chosen to keep that ability away from us mere mortals.
- Jesse

1 Comment

  1. Javier Miranda

    All the new features of FileMaker 9 are steps in the right direction, looking at the posibilities regarding interface you can find in other software you find out the limitations of FileMaker, particulary I find a great distance when using Revolution. I am sure the people in FileMaker are working and listening to us, the users, to provide us with a more object driven interface.

Tell Us What You Think

*
* (will not be published)